Skip to main content

Review: The Wind Rises




The Wind Rises, if you believe director and animation legend Hayao Miyazaki, is to be the last film of his career. If that is the case, he will be leaving us with the most divisive work of his filmography.

Based loosely on the life of Jiro Horikoshi, The Wind Rises follows Jiro from his dreams of flying machines as a small boy to the man who created the Zero fighter. The film begins in a dream of Jiro's, the boy flying a plane in the sky with nary a care. Jiro's pleasant flight is ended quickly as German zeppelins infiltrate his dreams dropping bombs over the idyllic Japanese countryside.

Jiro's talents as an engineering student will be the only way for him to realize his dreams of flight. Inspired by Italian aero-designer Giovanni Caproni, Jiro aims to create some of the most innovative work known to mankind. Miyazaki's film chronicles Jiro's life starting from his childhood, to the Great Kanto Earthquake of 1923, through the Great Depression, and Japan's entrance into World War II.

Designing the Zero Fighter Plane was the sole devotion of Jiro's life -- he thinks of nothing else and does nothing else. Even in dreams he thinks only of his next project and simultaneously converses with Giovanni Caproni. Set about creating his masterpiece many scenes feature Jiro doing nothing more than humming and fiddling about with his slide rule. As such he is a blank canvas, any personality present is brought there by the viewer.

The Wind Rises is a beautiful looking film and the story of Jiro Horikoshi is an interesting one, but unfortunately Hayao Miyazaki's efforts ultimately fall short. Gorgeous animation and fanciful sound design aside, when it comes to actualizing Jiro's story onscreen, The Wind Rises risks alienating viewers with its depiction of events during the Second World War.

Jiro and Caproni discuss war and the cost is has on their dreams and ambitions, but they glide right over the cost of human life. Caproni chooses to overlook these details and compares their planes to the pyramids, saying he would rather live in a world with the Egyptian pyramids than without. Jiro aligns himself with this line of ideology, but he never questions whether the slaves who died making those pyramids might wonder if that creation was worth all of their lives.

With Jiro's moral dilemmas soothed, he doggedly pursues designing the next level machine for Mitsubishi. Director Miyazaki never mentions that the Zero Fighter itself was built by Chinese and Korean slave labor, a bit of information which colors that debate between Jiro and Caproni significantly. This incongruity with history, along with many others in the film, is hard to ignore and makes 'Wind' even harder to enjoy.

The depiction of Nazi bombs being dropped over Japan suggests that Jiro's country was a victim of Nazi Germany when, in reality, the two countries were allies. Many times The Wind Rises lays the groundwork, presenting Japan as defending the homeland when the reality is far different. That may not be Miyazaki's intention, but viewers might come to that conclusion given that Jiro never mourns the victims, only the planes. Even in an ill-advised bit of fictional romance, Jiro seems to exist more as a passer-by than a person concerned with Nahoko's ultimate care.

In trying to keep from angering his fellow countrymen, Miyazaki may have made Jiro's internal conflict as subtle as possible, but it feels like it just isn't there. What cements that feeling is that when Jiro visits his Zeroes in a field of wreckage, he laments not human life, but that more of his planes didn't return to him.

Hayao Miyazaki has been very vocal about the negative effects of ignoring the atrocities of WWII, but sadly, the point of view he means to focus The Wind Rises on fails to get that point home. Unfortunately the exceptional beauty of Miyazaki's hand-drawn work of is overshadowed by the circumstances. Miyazaki may have found a man of similar passion in Jiro Horikoshi, but in capturing that passion, he opened the door for many more interpretations than he intended.

The Wind Rises is a complex film and one sure to arouse many different feelings. I may not have liked it, but I highly recommend that you give it a shot and decide for yourself.

Popular posts from this blog

Paprika vs. Inception

Months before Inception hit the theaters forums were alive with rumors that Christopher Nolan either accidentally or intentionally stole some details from another film, the Japanese anime Paprika. The biggest point of comparison for some bloggers and forum runners was the fact that both of the films featured a device that allowed a person, or people, to travel into another’s dreams and delve into their subconscious.
Minor points of comparison include scenes in Paprika where the character Paprika breaks through a mirrored wall by holding her hand to it, as well as a scene where a police detective falls his way down a hallway. Claims have been made that Inception abounds with imagery similar to or exactly like the anime movie, but with the recent release of the film on DVD and Blu-Ray, and with Paprika available for several years now, an examination of the two plots can be made more fully.
Let us begin with the primary claim—Inception stole the idea of a dream machine from Paprika. It …

Herman Melville and Office Space

Just from gleaning the surface of Office Space one would assume that there isn't anything simmering below the surface except for a raunchy work-comedy, but they would be wrong.
After the harsh critical reception of his greatest work Moby Dick Melville wrote a collection of short stories called Bartleby and Benito Cereno perhaps the greatest slam at the time against industrial America. Bartleby is the story of a Wall Street copyist who has his three employees proof-read and copy law forms. Shortly into the story Bartleby starts responding to work commands with, "I would prefer not to." Frustrated by his employee's subordination the Narrator tries to have him fired but Bartleby refuses to leave the office. The Narrator comes back the following morning to find Bartleby living inside his office. Bartleby becomes increasingly less apt to perform basic functions as eating after he is jailed for trespassing and dies in a jail cell. What at once starts out as a comedy has …

Blumhouse's Truth or Dare Giveaway

We’re not playing the game, it’s playing us! A harmless game of "Truth or Dare" among friends turns deadly when someone--or something--begins to punish those who tell a lie--or refuse the dare. Blumhouse’s Truth or Dare, opening in theaters Friday the 13th! To celebrate the release of this terrifying new film we have a Truth or Dare giveaway for readers. Play the app below with a friend and take the Truth or Dare challenge to see who survives. To enter, tag a friend you'd bring along to the film to @wordsbycbiggs on Twitter and use the #TruthOrDareMovie hashtag. One lucky winner will receive a prize pack, which includes: 1 - Limited Edition Truth or Dare Card Game: This limited edition Truth or Dare Game is only available via this promotion and has a run of 200 pieces worldwide. It has a card deck featuring dares and the creepy crawly items you need to satisfy the dares in the deck. Test your resolve… The truth will set you free! 1 - Truth or Dare Official Promo Tank - O…