Skip to main content

Review: Lone Survivor

War films that don't star John Wayne typically do not do well in cinemas. Scratch that, with the exception of Saving Private Ryan, these movies don't do well. Whether it's just too soon or depicting an unpopular war, war films are not something audiences clamor to see. Kathryn Bigelow's The Hurt Locker took a step in a different direction by aiming at recreating a soldier's experience rather than shaping a political slant out of the story.

Aiming for a picture that captures the brotherly bonds of being a Navy SEAL rather than making a comment on the war in Afghanistan, Peter Berg goes the same route as Bigelow. Based on Marcus Luttrell's real-life account of "Operation Red Wings," the director spares no detail in his recreation of the failed mission to capture and kill Taliban target Ahmad Shah.

Four members of SEAL Team 10 were tasked with the mission to capture or kill Taliban leader Ahmad Shah. These four men are Marcus Luttrell (Mark Wahlberg), Michael Murphy (Taylor Kitsch), Danny Dietz (Emile Hirsch) and Matt Axelson (Ben Foster). From the very beginning of Lone Survivor the audience is witness to the close, intense bonds that SEALs forge over the course of their training. It's a nice use of visual shorthand that keeps the runtime brief without cutting valuable material elsewhere.

The mission is doomed almost from the start. Bad intel places the four SEALs in a Taliban stronghold with no air support or extraction options. Shah is within their sights, but the shot is too far to take. Communications with HQ are lost, and bad news keep pouring on like Murphy's law was created specifically for this operation. Three local villagers stumble across the SEALs hideout and a decision no one wants to make is suddenly forced upon them: kill them, or let them go back and give up their hiding spot.

There is much less build-up to the action here than in other films. What begins merely as an scouting expedition turns into an assault against a small army. Options are limited: they either go down the mountain or wait for communication links to go back up. Left with no recourse and no backup, Luttrell and crew decide to fight their way out.

Fun fact: without Battleship this film wouldn't exist, so the next time someone asks if there is any redeeming value to that story you can tell them that. Peter Berg obviously holds the material in reverence and, for the most part, he does justice to it. Berg has a passion for the warrior culture that is the Navy SEALs and he captures the intensity of fighting under fire with brothers-in-arms. The four are never rattled, they just go about the business of trying to get home in one piece. Though we know that most won't.

Titling the film Lone Survivor reveals almost too much about the course of the story. From the very beginning it's obvious that only one soldier makes it, and that informs the very bleak outlook for the rest of the movie. To its credit that also removes the hyper-exaggerated, move-like aspects of the film as well. The only remaining cliche being some of the dialogue during Axleson's last stand, but they sound reasonable coming from Ben Foster's mouth.

Lone Survivor does not possess the complete authenticity of something along the lines of Act of Valor, but great acts of courage are still to be found. These four men gave it all and that is not lost on the director.

Yet, before the term propaganda is thrown about let's stop and consider that the poor decisions made up the food chain that doom Operation Red Wings and the devastating losses that occurred are hardly a recruiting tool. What's more is that a great deal of the story gives credit to the Pashtun villagers that takes Luttrell in and protects him from Taliban forces, particularly Gulab (Ali Suliman), the sacrifice of those villagers earns a special mention before the credits roll.

This film is a hard watch, but certainly a worthy one.



Popular posts from this blog

Hulk vs. The Incredible Hulk vs. The Avengers

There are two movies about the Hulk and one that features the green monster as a major player. One was made in 2003 by an auteur, starring a little-known Aussie. Five years later The Incredible Hulk came out to the same tepid reaction as Ang Lee's Hulk did. This weekend, The Avengers made the Hulk as popular as he has been in a long time. So it comes down to this: Hulk vs. Hulk vs. Hulk. Who will smash whom?

Round One: Acting
Edward Norton outshines Eric Bana as the dual persona of the meek Bruce Banner and the rage-induced Hulk. Eric Bana was given little to do but run and fight and often the audience was just waiting for him to transform. With the Incredible Hulk, Norton's Banner is fully fleshed-out and we are given a reason to care about him. Being allowed to go a little dark with Banner's scenes questioning what is left of his life provided emotional resonance to the character that Hulk lacked. Yet even with the capable performance that Norton gives there was something …

Review: The Salvation

Westerns have never recovered from the oversaturation that killed off viewer interest decades ago, but every now and then a gem pops up. Recent successes like The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford, 2007’s 3:10 to Yuma and the Coen brothers adaptation of True Grit all did well because they tweaked the genre slightly, but director Kristian Levring goes with an old school approach. A faithful recreation of those revenge Westerns made so popular in the 1970s, The Salvation envelopes many elements of previous Clint Eastwood classics and wraps it into a tidy package.

The Salvation starts in on the central dilemma, joining Jon (Hannibal‘s Mad Mikkelsen) at the train station where he awaits the arrival of his wife and son. Jon and his brother, Peter (Mikael Persbrandt), have lived in the United States long enough to build a hospitable life for their family back in Denmark. This homecoming should be a sweet moment to establish the family important to Jon, but fate plays out…

Review: The Voices

Jerry (Ryan Reynolds) spends his days working the nine-to-five shift at his new job at the Milton Bathtub Factory. Jerry is chipper to the point that he may turn some people off, but he never stops trying to make friends. Friends are something that Jerry could use because the only other conversation he has is with his dog Bosco and his cat Mr. Whiskers. Things are looking up though, Jerry has been tasked with planning the company picnic and he’s asked a girl (Gemma Arterton) out on a date. Jerry is so excited to share the news he rushes home to tell his pets about Fiona. Oddly enough, both Bosco and Mr. Whiskers start talking back.

No need to go back and re-read that last sentence, yes, Ryan Reynolds has pets who talk back to him. His dog, Bosco, is quite affable, however, his cat, Mr. Whiskers, would feel right at home curled in the lap of Blofeld. Unfortunately for everyone around him, it’s the advice of the evil cat that Jerry heeds more often than not. For all of Jerry’s pleasant…